| Comment ID | Country | Clause | Paragraph | Type | Comments | Proposed Change |
| KR-0001 | KR | All | ge | Harmonization: DIS 29500 does not have any specifications to ensure interoperability for ISO/IEC 26300 approved asthe international standard to exchange office documents without any limitations. If DIS 29500 is approved without securing interoperability, it would give confusion to both a market and users |
DIS 29500 should provide a faithful interoperability for ISO/IEC 26300(ODF) not by plug-in translators but by DIS 29500 itself, as it does for the legacy binary format. | |
| KR-0002 | KR | te | Platform
dependency: DIS 29500 lacks supports for other platforms and browsers. It restricts the use of Linux platform and browsers such as FireFox, Opera and Safari |
DIS 29500 should support various platforms and browsers such as Linux, FireFox, Opera and Safari | ||
| KR-0003 | KR | Part 1, 15.2.14 | te | DEVMODE structure lacks cross-platform adaptability as print settings be stored in a platform specific binary format | DIS 29500 should support various platforms and browsers such as Linux, FireFox, Opera and Safari | |
| KR-0004 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.2.32 | te | ‘optimizeForBrowser’ element of WordProcessingML is defined in a way which ignores the existing browsers other than IE. For example, Firefox, Safari, Opera are not supported and all settings will be disabled in these browsers | DIS 29500 should support various platforms and browsers such as Linux, FireFox, Opera and Safari | |
| KR-0005 | KR | Part 4, 6.4.3.1 | te | The ‘Clipboard Format Type’ allowed in this element are all Windows-platform formats; Bitmap(Bitmap), Pict(EMF), PictOld(WMF), PictPrint(Printer Picture). PNG format used in Linux platform is not allowed | DIS 29500 should support various platforms and browsers such as Linux, FireFox, Opera and Safari | |
| KR-0006 | KR | te | Insufficient
information for legacy application behaviours: Many elements in DIS 29500 mimic legacy application behaviours However, the draft does not contain sufficient details on how to replicate these behaviours |
The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | ||
| KR-0007 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.26 | te | footnoteLayoutLikeWW8 : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0008 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.31 | te | lineWraplikeWord6 : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0009 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.32 | te | mwSmallCaps : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0010 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.41 | te | shapeLayoutLikeWW8 : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0011 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.53 | te | truncateFontHeightsLikeWP6 : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0012 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.54 | te | uiCompat97To2003 : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0013 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.6 | te | autoSpaceLikeWord95 : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0014 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.63 | te | useWord2002TableStyleRles : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0015 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.64 | te | useWord97LineBreakRules : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0016 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.65 | te | wpJustification : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0017 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.3.66 | te | wpSpaceWidth : unknown application behaviour | The details of application behaviours should be described in Part 5.11 ,’Application-Defined Extension Elements” | |
| KR-0018 | KR | te | Re-use of the
existing standards: DIS 29500 incorporates very little of existing standards. Instead, it demands to use the specific vendor’s proprietary and the legacy formats, even though the relevant standards exist. Approving DIS 29500 would result in reinventing the wheel for the existing standards giving inconvenience to users |
DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML | ||
| KR-0019 | KR | Part 4, 3.17.4.1 | te | Date Representation : it conflicts with ISO 8601 | DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML | |
| KR-0020 | KR | Part 4, 2.18.52 | te | ST_LangCode : it conflicts with ISO 639 | DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML | |
| KR-0021 | KR | Part 4, 6.2.3.17 | te | ST_OLELinkType : It uses Enhanced metafile instead of ISO/IEC 8632 | DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML | |
| KR-0022 | KR | Part 4, 6.4.3.1 | te | ST_OLELinkType : It uses windows metafile instead of ISO/IEC 8632 | DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML | |
| KR-0023 | KR | Part 4, 5 | te | DrawingML Reference Material : it conflicts with W3C SVG | DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML | |
| KR-0024 | KR | Part 4, 2.15.1.28 | te | documentProtection :The element does not adopt the existing standards such as ISO/IEC 10118-3, W3C XML-ENC but it defines new hashing algorithms | DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML | |
| KR-0025 | KR | Part 4, 4.6.1 | te | Anim(Animate): it contradicts with W3C SMIL(Synchronized Multimedia Integration Language) | DIS 29500 should use the existing standards and remove VML and DrawingML |